U.S. Court: Laptops Can Be Seized Without Cause at Borders

If a U.S. Border Patrol agent wants to look at—and inside—your laptop when you cross the U.S. border—he doesn’t need a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity to perform the search, a U.S. court has held.

In response, dozens of organizations, including the Association of Corporate Travel Executives, have sent an open letter to four congressional committees, asking them to consider legislation that will “protect all Americans against suspicionless digital border inspections.”

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit handed down the laptop ruling April 21. The case involved a man named Michael Arnold, who was arrested in 2005 on charges of transporting child pornography on his laptop. The unanimous three-judge decision reverses a lower court finding that customs agents needed some reasonable suspicion that a crime had occurred in order to search a traveler’s laptop.

ACTE filed a friend of the court brief in the case, arguing that a laptop was intellectual property and, therefore, different from ordinary luggage. “The court has disagreed, and this decision will have significant impact on business travelers who have no idea their data is subject to search and seizure,” said ACTE Global Executive Director Susan Gurley in a statement responding to the court’s decision.

ACTE has been following the laptop seizure issue for several years. After the court decision, the association issued a warning to its members, and all business travelers, to limit proprietary information on laptop computers when crossing U.S. borders and to eliminate any personal data, including photographs, finances, and e-mail that they do not want examined by Border Patrol authorities.

While Gurley called for Congress to act on the laptop seizure issue, she recognizes the challenges. “In a time of heightened international security, it will take a brave Congress to rule that parties may not be subject to suspicionless searches,” said Gurley. She said she expects the issue to come up again, perhaps “when a more compelling case winds its way to the Supreme Court.”

         Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines

Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2008 Penton Media Inc.

Meetings Collaborative

Rate your experience with meeting venues and suppliers.

Facility / Hotel

 
Powered by: Meetings Collaborative

The Meeting Planning Blog

Face2Face Latest Posts

Webinars

Is This Meeting Really Necessary? Owning Visibility and Control of Your Company's Meetings Spend

Tuesday, June 24, 2008 at 1:00pm ET

Join Corporate Meetings & Incentives’ newest columnist, Betsy Bondurant, formerly of Amgen and now a meetings management consultant, for a free eye-opening web seminar on strategic meetings management. Discover how you can better control your corporate-wide meetings spend without losing the strategic value of your meetings and events. Webinar Registration


Back to Top

Explore Our Newsletters

Meeting Planner Survival Guide

NEW & IMPROVED! Whether you're a novice planner or a veteran, this compilation of must-read articles is your meeting planning resource.

Suppliers/
Facilities/CVBs

MeetingsNet makes it easy to find the CVB, tourist boards, and facilities you need for your next meeting.

Deals &
Discounts

Special group hotel offers brought to you by MeetingsNet.

Find A Job

Targeted to all aspects of the hospitality and special events industry.

Education
Central

Upcoming Events, Live and Online

Inside Current Issue

June AM

June 2008

April AM

April 2008

Feb MTNGS Cover

February 2008

Dec MTNGS Cover

December 2007

Oct MTNGS Cover

October 2007

Browse Back Issues